DEBATE THREAD!!!!

Chatterbox: Down to Earth

DEBATE THREAD!!!!

DEBATE THREAD!!!!!!!!!!

Yo humans!!!!!  Sorry I havnt been around much.  busy busy busy...

Anyways I'm starting a debate thread where we can debate over problems solutions and such.  

Since I am the creator of this thread I and only I will pick out the questions.  

When we surmise we are at the end of a discusion I shall pick out a new question for us to debate over!!!!!!!!

FIRST QUESTION!!!!!!

*drum role please...

SHOULD PLUTO BE CONSIDERED A PLANET?  WHY OR WHY NOT??????????

So there you are, I'll wait for this to pop up before I state my theories.  ;-) 

submitted by Windswift
(September 11, 2016 - 7:50 pm)

Omigoodness!!!! That's awsome icy!!! And yeah I agree with everyone, Pluto should totally be a planet, a dwarf planet no lease.  Aren't scientists debating over to change the rules of what makes a planet a planet?  

Anyways NEW QUESTION!!!!!!

Which of theses two are more real--pirates or ninjas?????????? 

submitted by Windswift
(September 14, 2016 - 8:56 pm)

pirates. They are real, people. 

But on the other hand, so are ninjas.  

submitted by Daisy
(September 15, 2016 - 7:00 am)

Ummmmmmmmmmmm. What do you mean? Both were real, but have died out. Pirates might not have.

submitted by Impunity Jane
(September 16, 2016 - 11:25 am)

Thank you, Icy, for posting the definitions... I was going to do that but am too lazy and hoped that someone would've posted it before me. You just made my day.

Tycho says arop. I wonder if he's been listening to rop (er... rap) music?

submitted by B. Dino, age Immortal, CBer Heaven
(September 18, 2016 - 6:53 pm)

(Note: This is a joke, don't take this seriously.)

Pluto should be! Okay, imagine being part of a small town and havig big dreams. Yuo want to move to the big city! And finally, you do! Everyone loves you! your adorable, record breaking, and a great addition to the city. You make friends with Venus and Saturn. You follow in the footsteps of your idol, the Sun. And then a big guy in a suit comes around and measures you and kicks you out of the city becuase you are too small. And you realize your whole life was a lie. And your kitten runs away. That's what it would be like to be Pluto. So have some sympathy. Consider Pluto a planet. 

submitted by Savvy44x
(September 15, 2016 - 8:20 am)

Pirates!Cus there were REAL PIRATS!!Dunno about ninjas...Anywho!I dont like pirates cus oh i dunno THEY KILLED PEOPLE AND TOOK (spelled that horrobly) THERE TRESURE!!!!

tux

 

submitted by Tuxedo kitten
(September 15, 2016 - 8:50 am)

I'd say pirates. Ninjas also existed but I'm going to say pirates because they actually still exist while I'm pretty sure that real-life ninja assassins are over and done with. 

Tux is right – real life pirates are simply nothing more that seafaring robbers. Nothing like the romanticized version in modern media like Pirates of the Carribbean... even though Jack Sparrow is hilarious. 

submitted by Somebody, age Who cares, Various places
(September 15, 2016 - 7:31 pm)

They were both real, but I'm gonna say...

I CAN'T DECIDE!!!

Probably Pirates. Ninjas are highly romanticized. 

submitted by Icy , age 12!!!, The Forest
(September 16, 2016 - 8:46 am)

Hmmm... both ninjas and pirates are awesome, but I'd say pirates are more real. There are a lot of them off the coast of Somalia. Jack Sparrow is amazing, by the way. I watched that movie yesterday, and am probably about to watch the first one with my brothers tonight. They are hilarious.

submitted by The Riddler
(September 17, 2016 - 5:57 pm)

I can't really tell which is 'more real'. 

Ninjas, as far as I remember, were families of assassins hired to combat governmental forces-- let me go double-check that.

So I looked them up on Wikipedia (yay me!!!)-- turns out they were a band of agents-for-hire, appearing during the unrest of the Sengoku period. They gathered information primarily, and also performed assassinations and other handy political services. It didn't say anything about ninja-families-- I think I just read that in a kid's fictional-history book like thing. 

Pirates weren't as swashbuckling and desperate as modernly portrayed-- there was a pirate who wore a powdered wig, treated his men kindly and did buisness transactions with opponents. It was a financial thing-- emperors and monarchs were always pillaging ships. The only difference between them and pirates, it would seem, were their authority levels.  

submitted by Esthelle (Es-thel-ay, age Anonymous, Rivendell (I wish) ;)
(September 17, 2016 - 10:07 pm)

John Hancock was a sort of a pirate! (sorry: random facts from history class)

submitted by The Riddler
(September 18, 2016 - 6:30 pm)

I'm a little late, but...

PLUTO WILL ALWAYS BE A PLANET TO ME. I DON"T CARE ABOUT SCIENCE. OHANA MEANS FAMILY. FAMILY MEANS NO ONE GETS LEFT BEHIND.  

#Viva la Pluto 

submitted by Bluebird
(September 18, 2016 - 11:21 am)

Yeah blue!!! *high fives blue bird*

NEW QUESTION!!!!!!

drum roll please.....

WHICH IS BETTER EQUIPPED TO SURVIVE IN THE WILD, CATS OR DOGS?????? (feral and wild)

submitted by Windswift
(September 19, 2016 - 3:41 pm)

DOGS!!

Waddaya mean, I need more proof than that? It comes down to my personal expirience. This is a scary, and true story.

Icy was walking her tiny, adorable, yet ferocious, yet cuddly and kind, yet playful, dog down the sidewalk. She gazed ahead, and stepped forward. Until, in the yard of the blue house, she saw a dog, simply lying, peaceful, under a tree. She was two steps away from it. And then she saw the mange, the color, the body shape, and knew that it wasn't a dog. She had never been this close to one, but she knew. It was one of the things that howled in her neighborhood, if you stayed up late enough to hear it resounding from the nearby prairie.

It was a coyote, and she was two steps away from it. She stared, and her dog, normally playful with other dogs, was still, just standing there, staring at the Coyote. And the Coyote stared back, with calm eyes. And all Icy could do was start crying. And then, after minutes of standing there crying, petrified, she turned, and ran.

Ran, all the way home. (Later, she would wonder how her dog was smart enough to differentiate between Coyotes and normal dogs.) She burst upstairs and, breathless, sobbed and told her story. Her dad took her out for a drive nearby, to see it from a window, after she had begged. (He also was driving slow in the neighborhood and playing Pokemon Go in the car.)

It was still lying there. They got close, and saw it, and then..it moved. It had a limp, a leg in the back, and a paw in the front. It was hurt, but not visibly other than the limp. That was why it was out, away from the prairie (they did venture away--once we saw one just strolling down the sidewalk--but never during the day like I saw it.). They called Animal Control, hoping that they could save the poor thing, and then--

"Coyotes are hard to catch. We've only caught a dozen in about the last 25 years. They're also resilient, and can survive in the wild, even with a bad limp like that, and it will live naturally." So there you go. Animal Control aproved. As for cats--unless they're lepoards and jaguars, I would NEVER rate them under dogs. My dog, although small, could definitely hunt and survive in the wild. Not to say that cats couldn't, though.

submitted by Icy, age 12!!!, The Forest
(September 19, 2016 - 8:36 pm)

Cats are more equipped to survive in the wild for the following reasons:

1.) Cats are less dependant upon humans to survive. When you have a cat, you just need to buy food, water, a scratching post... and it will take care of itself. Just a bit of love, and voila! A perfect pet. Dogs, on the other hand, need you to pick up their litter constantly, and you need to walk them every single morning... how would they survive without your love? They would mope around 'till the day they die. Cats are more "lonely" creatures, the reason why they are the ideal pet for authors. Authors need to devote more time to writing stories, and can't take the time to give a dog all the love it needs, and a cat can just take care of itself much, much better. It can catch its own food, birds, mice, fish... while dogs need you to give their their dog food. Have you ever heard of a dog in the wild catching fish and spitting out the bones? Probably not, unless it's Superdog. Cats? You don't need to be Supercat to be able to catch a fish and spit out the bones.

2.) Cats are more agile and warrior-like, the exact reason Erin Hunter used them for her "Warriors" book. Sure, she wrote about dogs, too, but they weren't 'warriors' like cats were, and they aren't as popular, because cats being warriors and suriving out in the wild is just more realistic. Definitely more realistic. Cats crouch low on the ground in a tree, waiting for prey to come their way. Dogs are more clumsy, and they can't exactly climb trees. I mean, some can, but those some are more examples of "Superdog!" That's why cats, the smart creatures, escape by climbing trees, knowing that their agility can save their lives. The pounce quickly, snatching birds out of the air, therefore being able to eat and survive out in the wild. 

3.) Cats are less prone to diseases like rabies, which are more common to dogs. Cats have longer lives, the average life span of a cat being 21 years, and a dog being only 10-13 years. That's just because cats don't get sick as much. In books, it's usually the dog who gets sick or old and dies, like in Wonder. But cats don't. Crookshanks? Healthy as ever! And they are tough! In Plain Kate, *Spoiler Alert* Taggle dies, but does so heroicaly, and at the end still comes back to life and lives, because cats just battle on bravely. Something as trivial as death could never stop him!*Spoiler Ends* And his siblings, Raggle and Bone? Kings and Queens of the cats! All three survived against all odds. Bet a dog couldn't do that, huh? As for real life, the percentage of sick dogs with rabies and stuff like that are much more than cats, even wild cats and wild dogs. 

So those are my three reasons why cats would survive in the wild much better than dogs.

 

submitted by Alexandra
(September 19, 2016 - 8:42 pm)